Well-intended citizens want to do the right thing and put everything in the recycle bin. That generates a great deal of contamination and a lot of work for workers at the Material Recovery Facility (MRF), the facility where material collected is separated and similar items grouped/bailed together. Some degree of contamination is always expected, but excessive contamination jeopardizes the process and the material collected has to be sent to the landfills. In the end, all that effort "to do the right thing" ends up being in vain.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6deb5/6deb5dde50d5976d693279a7b6973ee3d0050508" alt=""
That was in 1988 and the plastic industry was able to announce that they "address[ed] the concerns of environmentalists, industrialists and state governments seeking a way to tame and organize the matter of plastics recovery."
Why? Different chemicals are used in the recipe of each product depending on their use. Even though products like bottles, trash can, and laundry baskets contain plastic #2 as their main component and are marked with the chasing arrows with #2 in them, "their chemical recipes are as different as their forms because each was manufactured for a different purpose, in a different manner, by a different machine. The recipe that works for a machine that air-inflates bottles all day is not the same as that which is required for a machine injecting plastics into molded cups." If those plastics are melted together, what we end up with is an unusable plastic soup that manufacturers can't put through their machines.
And where does that leave us?
The RIC system was not meant to be used by consumers; it was not meant to be a guide for you to decide whether or not your plastic can go in the recycle bin. Knowing that you cannot rely on the RIC in the middle of chasing arrows to determine whether or not an item is recyclable will lead you to other actions:
1. Look at the shape of the container
2. Look for clear indication (e.g a list from your recycling service provider) of what is acceptable
3. Contact your local Solid Waste Department offices to know exactly what can/cannot go in the recycle bin
4. Look for alternative programs, like Terracycle, to recycle more of your packaging
5. Demand changes and the adoption of clear labels from manufacturers
The How2Recycle Label program finished its soft launch in early 2012 and has now over 45 participating companies and brands.
Their goals match what consumers need to become better recyclers and what recycling service providers need to make their process more efficient:
- Reduce confusion by creating a clear, well-understood, and nationally harmonized label (http://www.how2recycle.info/labels) that enables industry to convey to consumers how to recycle a package.
- Improve the reliability, completeness, and transparency of recyclability claims.
- Provide a labeling system that follows Federal Trade Commission Green Guides (http://www.ftc.gov/policy/federal-register-notices/guides-use-environmental-marketing-claims-green-guides).
- Increase the availability and quality of recycled material.
How2Recycle
began in 2008, and is a project of the Sustainable Packaging Coalition.
The How2Recycle Label program finished its soft launch in early 2012
and now has over 45 participating companies and brands. - See more at:
http://www.how2recycle.info/about#sthash.HIJzgGMx.dpuf
So don't decide what can go in the bin by merely looking at a meaningless RIC on the bottom of a container. Go further and try the five steps listed above. Think of RIC as a thing from the past. It's time to give way to a better labeling system and start recycling better.
Read on...
Symbols on containers
http://www.triplepundit.com/2014/08/plastics-recycling-youre-wrong-everybody-else/
Alternative labeling
http://greenblue.org/work/how2recycle/
Recycling Plastic Is Surprisingly Complex. Here’s What Happens After the Bin.
https://magazine.good.is/infographics/what-happens-after-the-bin